Skip to top navigationSkip to shopping bagSkip to main contentSkip to footer links
SHOP WOMENSHOP MENDetails

Reviews

Review Snapshot
4.2
115 Star Ratings
91%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Most Liked Positive Review
⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolute stunning dress, but SIZE UP!

I love everything about this dress! As a tall woman (5'8"), finding the perfect length is tough, but this hits right at my ankles—making it perfect for both flats and heels. It also features adjustable straps and pockets, which is a huge plus. Fit note: The bodice runs extremely snug. I'm a 36C and...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
The tiniest corset

I wear a Petite 4 or BR Small (5'2", 117 lbs, 34C), but this size 4 didn't work for my frame. The skirt is cool. It has plenty of volume and weight, though the fabric is heavier than expected and may be too warm for summer. The corset top, though, is tiny - I couldn't get the zipper past my waist. S...

Write a Review
108 Customer Reviews
Good dress size up sit down when trying on breathe deep

Submitted 1 day ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about Soft Cotton Corset Maxi Dress

It's a beautiful sturdy made dress. Thing with women's bodies is that we grow with our cycles and our curves make it difficult to determine exact measurements standing and sitting. So this dress has zero stretch. It is a corset style dress. I normally wear a size 4 to 6 and I chose the size 10 dress so that my ribs would not crush when I sat down and breathed in deeply. In-order to get the size 10 to fit my ribcage I will have to take it to a tailor to get cups inserted so that I can also take it in a slight bit so it will fit my breasts as it is too roomy there. It also became more roomy around the hips which I didn't need but it still looks nice just changed the look significantly to a little more formal. I wish the dress had a few slits of stretch along the side and back rib area. I do believe our era has experienced the true liberation of stretch in our clothes so taking it all away for a structured dress that is not tailored for each individual woman who tries the dress is going to be difficult to fit well in all areas of the dress. Because it was on sale I decided I would invest in taking it to a tailor to get cups inserted but I would not have had to if there were even a few slits with stretch in the ribcage area. My fear is if my breasts grow a bit or if they take in the cups will it be against too tight on the ribcage when I sit? Beautiful dress but I am quite small framed but very curvy and I think this dress is not going fit quite a lot of women as well as it could have. For me it is worth altering but I don't actually know if that was wise or if this dress will sustain me for the next year to come.

⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolute stunning dress, but SIZE UP!

Submitted 7 days ago

By AZ

From Undisclosed

I love everything about this dress! As a tall woman (5'8"), finding the perfect length is tough, but this hits right at my ankles—making it perfect for both flats and heels. It also features adjustable straps and pockets, which is a huge plus. Fit note: The bodice runs extremely snug. I'm a 36C and bought a size 6, but I really wish I could have tried an 8 (unfortunately, it's sold out). The breast cups run a bit short, so if you are larger than a C cup, I highly recommend sizing up one or even two sizes. Overall, it is incredibly elegant, versatile enough to dress up or down, and a fantastic wardrobe staple!

Fits everywhere but the chest is too small. Stunning dress.

Submitted 8 days ago

By Vivien K

From Undisclosed

Sizing up will not work as the waist would be too loose. I have to get it altered and that will use up fabric from the length and cost more money. The chest is too small to zip up and I'm an A cup with a 20.5 BMI. Ordered a 2P. Which is what I wear with all BR clothes. Maybe it's just like that with the petites. The feel and weight of the fabric is very nice. The fullness of the skirt is perfect. The pattern and colors are gorgeous. I wish the detail at the waist were clean rather than the frills.

Wish Petite was longer

Submitted 14 days ago

By Anonymous

From Undisclosed

This is a very flattering dress but it was challenging to find the right size. I'm 5'4 129lbs 34 or 36A. I tried on 3 sizes. Size 2 was perfect in the bust and length but too tight in the torso. Size 4 was more comfortable but too big in the bust. Size 6P fit in the torso and bust but it only came up to my ankle which changed the silhouette. It's still gorgeous but a disappointment because the length is what makes it look regal.

Tall options

Submitted 22 days ago

By Shannon A

From Undisclosed

Beautiful dress, however it is disappointing that the company has chosen to eliminate dresses in true tall size. Hopefully they will realize that tall options are essential for those 511 and over, I am 6 feet tall and need the dresses to come in tall not Maxi size in regular length.

So many compliments

Submitted 24 days ago

By Berna, O

From Undisclosed

This dress is gorgeous!! Wore it to a wedding and got so many compliments. Love the heavy fabric and the design. Pockets!!!

Tricky to find a size

Submitted 26 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about Soft Cotton Corset Maxi Dress

As others have stated, the top of this dress is very small. The only other Banana Republic Petite item that I have is a pair of jeans that I bought in size 28P. According to the Petite size chart for this dress, a 28in waist corresponds to a size 6P. I could not zip up the 6P. Returned and bought the 8P. It zips up, but it's quite tight and hard to breathe. Returned and bought the 10P, and it's finally comfortable and fits well enough to keep. The petite length hits my ankles, which is perfect.

Tight in the chest

Submitted 29 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Soft Cotton Corset Maxi Dress

The dress is beautiful. It fits really tight in the bust. The cut is very flattering. The dress is worth the money.

Gorgeous dressed up or down

Submitted 1 month ago

By Janet

From Undisclosed

The black dress is what I like to call simple chic. The fabric elevates it enough to be able to dress it up for a nice event. I am 5'4, 135 lbs, 34b, 28 waist and normally wear a 4 in BR. I ordered a size 6P and the only thing "con" is that the dress isn't as long on me as it is on the model in the black dress. Not a dealbreaker, will be keeping.

Well made

Submitted 1 month ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about Soft Cotton Corset Maxi Dress

Only four stars because I was hoping it would be floor length. However It goes to just about my ankles. I'm 5'8. Otherwise fits like a glove no complaints. Quality is 10/10. Will be perfect for summer and my Europe trip.