Reviews

Review Snapshot
4.1
32 Star Ratings
80%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Most Liked Positive Review
hard to review

I bought this sweatshirt in green, against my normal buying rules to not pay for price, or pay the crazy nyc sales tax, in green in store in New York city. I was cold, the sweatshirt was soooo soft and I loved the color, despite the somewhat awkward sleeves. (and i'm a fan of 3/4 sleeves, these just...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
3/4 sleeves and odd fit

The sleeves end midway between my wrist and elbow, which is not clear from the photos. The fabric is nice (not really a sweatshirt) but I sized up one based on the model photos, and the cut was still clingy and emphasized every curve in a not flattering way.

Write a Review
30 Customer Reviews
hard to review

Submitted 1 day ago

By Sylke L

From Undisclosed

I bought this sweatshirt in green, against my normal buying rules to not pay for price, or pay the crazy nyc sales tax, in green in store in New York city. I was cold, the sweatshirt was soooo soft and I loved the color, despite the somewhat awkward sleeves. (and i'm a fan of 3/4 sleeves, these just hit a bit odd.) When they went on sale, I also ordered the blue and grey (more beige but ok). I tend to grab these a lot on chilly spring days, BUT depending on the color, they wear kind of badly. The grey was washed twice and kind of looks like a pilled rag. It also snags very easily (i have cats). All 3 colors have issues with the bottom trim. it gets very slobbery and does not look good if you don't half tuck it. You MUST dry this sweatshirt in the dryer in order to get its shape back, because if you hang it to dry it will just look weird. I'd say it is AY overpri=ced for the quality, even if on sale. Silly thing is, I do like them, i just wish the quality wasn't so lacking. All 3 colors seem to fit differently too despite the same fabric contents. My favorite at the moment is the navy, fit wise. Least favorite fit is probably the grey. Also, Do not hang these on a hanger. It will leave hanger marks due to the heavy fabric. (and because of that they take very long to dry as well). So, I kind of love/hate these sweatshirts.

Sizing is way off

Submitted 19 days ago

By Lori W.

From Undisclosed

Reviewed at

gap.com

I am usually an extra small so I sized up based on reviews. The small is still tiny. I could have accepted this but this sweater is very poorly made. The back is shorter than the front. Returning.

Better than a sweat sweatshirt

Submitted 20 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Garment Dye Sweatshirt

Although I would not call it a sweatshirt, I really like it! I can see whether the three-quarter length sleeves might bug people. It's not loose fitting so if you like the baggy fit, I would size up.

Awkward sweatshirt

Submitted 24 days ago

By Valerie S

From Undisclosed

I found the fit off. Large in body but short and sleeves tight and short. Did not material comfy.

So soft

Submitted 1 month ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Garment Dye Sweatshirt

Love this. Bought the blue one as well. I love the 3/4 sleeves.

Nice sweater!

Submitted 1 month ago

By Christina D.

From Undisclosed

I like this sweater! I got the green and really like the color. The fabric is really soft and this piece has washed well. The sleeves are kind of short but I like the look with a button up shirt underneath.

Beautiful colors and fabric.

Submitted 1 month ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Garment Dye Sweatshirt

Love this sweatshirt, have 3 different colors. All the colors are beautiful and have a slight washed effect. The fabric is substantial, the fit works. The sleeves are a little short, but I think meant to be pushed up or over a shirt with cuffs. Works for me.

Super soft

Submitted 2 months ago

By sheryl g

From Undisclosed

Loved it! Bought 2. Navy and gray, the gray is more like a beige which I prefer. Sleeves are great

Fabric and color awesome; Tricky fit

Submitted 2 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Garment Dye Sweatshirt

Reading the reviews, I purchased the XXL as I prefer a looser fit. It turned out to be really large in the arms and body and I returned it. I am tempted to order a L if it goes on sale again, but the neckline was very tight on the XXL, I'm concerned the L would be even more so, The fabric and color were beautiful, but the silhouette was a little off.

Why the Short Sleeves

Submitted 2 months ago

By Lindsay G

From Undisclosed

I tried this on in store and it's a beautiful sweater. Fabric is great, love the raglan style sleeve, but the sleeves were so short and not full length like they appear on the website. I really wanted to buy, the color was fantastic (chartreuse/yellow/green), but I need full length sleeves.