Normally I'm between a 9.5 and a 10. My foot measures just slightly over a 9.5. I initially ordered a 9.5, but barely fit. I exchanged for 10 and they fit, but if my foot were to swell significantly, they would be snug. I didn't want to move up to a 10.5 because confident they would be too big and too difficult to secure with the laces, given the leather laces are kind of tricky to adjust. My advice is to start with a half size bigger than your true size. Also, I think these are best for a normal width or slightly wider than normal. I could see these being too wide for narrow feet and / or long toes. The suede and color are just like the picture. The leather laces were much easier to adjust vs Sperry's. I also like the look and fit of rounder toe area vs Sperry's.

Once you wear a few times, they feel amazing. My new go-to shoe for errands and work.

I really like the shoe but runs small. I am always a 9 and these felt short and tight across the toe box. I reordered a half size up and hope it works.