Reviews

Review Snapshot
4.2
10 Star Ratings
83%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Overall size
Width
Most Liked Positive Review
Beautiful but sized up and too big

A beautiful elegant shoe, stylistically, and these would have worked on me, a size 8, or sometimes 7.5, but with a narrow foot. I sized up after reading reviews, but the shoe was too big (long) and my size had sold out. What a shame, they are gorgeous. I'll have to return them.

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
Sizing troubles

I bought both a size 5.5 and a size 6 after trying both on as a true women's size 6 (narrow foot) neither fit me perfectly. It might be due to the hard soul and hard leather that causes the shoe to not bend as one walks causing the back heel tab to slip up with every step. I think it's a perfect loa...

Write a Review
10 Customer Reviews
Stylish

Submitted 12 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Italian Leather Penny Loafer

Beautiful and stylish leather loafers - great design - simple and very comfortable. Some reviews listed as unforgiving leather and painful but i found them to be very comfortable . The leather is Italian and high quality and becomes very pliable after a few wears. Highly recommend. Wish they were included in the promo :(

Beautiful but sized up and too big

Submitted 1 month ago

By GTK

From Undisclosed

Reviewed at

gap.com

A beautiful elegant shoe, stylistically, and these would have worked on me, a size 8, or sometimes 7.5, but with a narrow foot. I sized up after reading reviews, but the shoe was too big (long) and my size had sold out. What a shame, they are gorgeous. I'll have to return them.

Uncomfortable look elsewhere

Submitted 2 months ago

By Jack, R

From Undisclosed

Aesthetically pleasing shoe, but terribly uncomfortable. I would look to other brands, especially for the price that these cost. I usually like BR so I'll come back, but these weren't it

Comfort

Submitted 2 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Italian Leather Penny Loafer

Fits comfortably and is very aesthetically pleasing

Sizing troubles

Submitted 2 months ago

By Alexis V

From Undisclosed

I bought both a size 5.5 and a size 6 after trying both on as a true women's size 6 (narrow foot) neither fit me perfectly. It might be due to the hard soul and hard leather that causes the shoe to not bend as one walks causing the back heel tab to slip up with every step. I think it's a perfect loafer on the market with all the features you could ask for, but unfortunately, how to return both pairs.

Quality

Submitted 3 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Italian Leather Penny Loafer

Loved the shoe & quality! Runs very small, size up . Wish I had seen customer acknowledgements before more purchase. Will need to return for larger size.

Lovely but small

Submitted 3 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about Italian Leather Penny Loafer

Well made but fits small—had to return

Classic must have

Submitted 3 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about Italian Leather Penny Loafer

Very simple classic loafers, just what I was looking for. My usual size was snug and I had to go up half a size for a better fit. It's well made too.

Tight

Submitted 3 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Italian Leather Penny Loafer

I am a solid size 9. My left foot is only slightly larger than my right. If I had to do it over again I would have gotten a size 9.5. I have only worn them indoors but the bottom is scuffed, so I wonder if I can return them. I love them so much but I fear they are a tad small.

Beautiful all leather loafer

Submitted 3 months ago

By Paula

From Undisclosed

Nice to find a true leather shoe,