Skip to top navigationSkip to shopping bagSkip to main contentSkip to footer links
SHOP WOMENSHOP MENDetails

Reviews

Review Snapshot
4.2
406 Star Ratings
93%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Most Liked Positive Review
Beautiful fair aisle colors

I am trying to love this fair aisle sweater. First out of the bag it's so striking with the blues,greens and orange. So festive. I normally buy Medium in sweaters and it's loose enough that it's not constricting. I read so many reviews that it runs small and I kept waiting for a Large to become avai...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
Shoulder seams stick out + pills too easily. Fit is good

Shoulder seams: the shoulder seams do not lay flat and instead stick out when worn. It looks sloppy. Material pills too easily: it looks and feels like it is about to pill even though I've only tried it on briefly. I got a merino sweater from here last year and it barely pills after many wears. ...

Write a Review
377 Customer Reviews
Not true to size

Submitted 1 day ago

By Hope M

From Undisclosed

I normally wear a small. When I pulled it out of the bag it looked like it was ordered for a child or had been shrunk. Laughably small and inaccurate.

Nice but Runs Small

Submitted 2 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

This sweater is a nice-quality basic that could be worn most (if not all) of the year, depending on the climate. It's a little scratchy so I don't think you would wear it alone. I am between an XS & a S, and I ordered the Small. I would characterize the fit as "shrunken," which means it's quite fitted & I won't be able to layer anything more than a very thin tee shirt underneath it.

Most comfortable sweater

Submitted 3 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

Perfect cozy sweater, perfect size.

Nice Fit

Submitted 6 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

I am very happy with this sweater! Being small framed, I always wear an XS and this is true to size. I wanted something fitted, not slouchy or oversized. It is warm without being heavy.

So soft and beautiful

Submitted 8 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

The aqua is such a beautiful color but I thought it might be a little itchy. It's not. It's soft and beautiful and I absolutely love it. It's true to size. I normallywear a small and I bought a small and it fits perfectly.

No no no

Submitted 10 days ago

By Nicky

From Undisclosed

I wish I'd seen the comments about shrinking before I bought this. I gave mine to a 9-year-old child, as it only fit her after the first wash. Disappointed to have wasted my money on this!!

Shrinks!

Submitted 12 days ago

By Keri B

From Undisclosed

Bought for Christmas not at this clearance price. Washed as directed and then I could barely put it on. Got it wet and tried to stretch it carefully. Dried even smaller. Returned. Store employee told me that they don't wash theirs. I bought a different merino/cotton sweater it also shrunk. It was very oversized so I could still wear it but I liked it better before.

Beautiful!!!

Submitted 14 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

A beautiful plush, soft and tts sweater. I have 5 of these sweaters and they are a true classic, with lovely detail stitching. The colors are beautiful too!!!!

Absolutely perfect!

Submitted 23 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

Great multi-season transitional sweater. Can be dressed up or down. A great basic to own.

Classic and Classy!!!

Submitted 27 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

This sweater is beautiful!! Classic and Classy!!! It fits tts and the wool is plush and not itchy! The detail stitching makes it stand out. I bought 4 colors, during the sale and got them for less than the price of 1, at regular price!! Thank you Banana Republic!!! I will wear them forever!!!