Reviews

Review Snapshot
4.2
343 Star Ratings
92%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Most Liked Positive Review
Beautiful fair aisle colors

I am trying to love this fair aisle sweater. First out of the bag it's so striking with the blues,greens and orange. So festive. I normally buy Medium in sweaters and it's loose enough that it's not constricting. I read so many reviews that it runs small and I kept waiting for a Large to become avai...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
Shoulder seams stick out + pills too easily. Fit is good

Shoulder seams: the shoulder seams do not lay flat and instead stick out when worn. It looks sloppy. Material pills too easily: it looks and feels like it is about to pill even though I've only tried it on briefly. I got a merino sweater from here last year and it barely pills after many wears. ...

Write a Review
318 Customer Reviews
Love the sweater but it shrank too much

Submitted 6 days ago

By Jen H.

From Undisclosed

Loved this sweater until I washed it.Followed the washing instructions and it shrank to the size of a child. So disappointed.

Quality Cotton Sweater

Submitted 6 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

Beautiful sweater, nice cut, fits true to size. Very temp regulating as day starts cool and warms.

Sweater shrank upon first wash

Submitted 7 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

The cut is amazing, the neck is small enough you can sz up 2 sizes and wear as a baggy option. Love the colors as well, stunning. The negatives, sweater began pulling on first wear. In first wash in cold water, sweater shrank to the extent I could no longer fit in it (this was not the sized up option). I ended up having to return the three i bought because I didn't want to have to dry clean

Pills

Submitted 9 days ago

By Ally P

From Undisclosed

I love the orange color and the fit, but it pilled on the second wear just from being under a coat. Not high quality.

Oretty but not perfect fabric

Submitted 10 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

It's lovely but it like pilling already before even washing

Shrinks!

Submitted 11 days ago

By Julie M

From Undisclosed

I wish I'd seen the comments about shrinking before I bought this, because they are right. Washing and air drying according to the care instructions results in a sweater that is more than one size smaller than the original. Plus the knit is stiff and tight so there's no give in it anymore. It's way too small and uncomfortable now. This purchase is a complete waste - I'd like my money back!

Pulled almost immediately

Submitted 12 days ago

By Michelle R

From Undisclosed

This was given to me as a gift and the cut/design was so flattering but it started pilling almost instantly. I was so sad because I really did like it but I'm not sure I've ever experience pilling happen so quickly.

Perfect fit, the orange is very pretty

Submitted 22 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

I bought size large in Orange. The colour is lovely and the fit is great. It is not cropped, but hits at the perfect length for high-waisted jeans, or for layering something underneath. I am usually medium or large, but based on the cut, I went with a large. Some others said the sleeves are tight, I thought they are just fine

Shrinks Terribly!

Submitted 23 days ago

By Connie S

From Undisclosed

Reviewed at

gap.com

I was excited about the sweater upon first receiving it. Received compliments on the colour/pattern. It shrunk considerably after washing, even after following the proper washing instructions. Such an expensive sweater and now it's best suited for a very young child, if at all. What a waste of money. I'm extremely disappointed for that and because I really liked it.

Awesome color but pills like crazy

Submitted 26 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about The Fireside Sweater in Merino-Cotton

Loved the color and cropped fit! But on day 1 of wearing it, the material was showing extreme pulling. I'm so disappointed because I picked this among several sweater options.