Reviews

Review Snapshot
4.5
30 Star Ratings
80%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Most Liked Positive Review
5 stars for warmth and quality. 2 stars for shipping

I love this piece! I appreciate the non syntetic lining and the amount of wool in the body. I like the cropped oversized look. For reference I'm 5'3'', 115 pounds, long legs, short torso. The XXS fits well, although I feel an XS would work as well. If I could rate shipping and fit consistency I woul...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
Disappointing design

I went to the store to try and buy the coat, but it turned to be fitting poorly with showers just hanging down. It is not a classic design but rather a trendy cropped oversized one with bulky sleeves. You can do better, Banana Republic, some things need to stay timeless and classy instead of running...

Write a Review
26 Customer Reviews
Very fast shipping and great protection for payment!

Submitted 19 days ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Italian Melton Wool-Blend Peacoat

It's lovely and quality Coat!! Incredible color ! I love it!

Warm & Stylish & real wool

Submitted 1 month ago

By Elle S

From Undisclosed

Reviewed at

gap.com

This coat checks all the boxes for being both stylish and practical. I always look for natural materials over plastic and this coat stood out amongst the polyester options out there by being 69% wool. The natural wool adds a layer of warmth that plastic fibres simply do not. The quality seems there but I took off a star for not having a replacement button sewn in the hem. For this price, I would expect the extra button. One button arrived slightly loose and fell off after a month of use. Luckily it wasn't lost so I could see the same button back on but I would have been disappointed to have lost one without an identical back-up.

Runs big

Submitted 1 month ago

By JoAnn

From Undisclosed

Very nice warm wool that's quality, but I had to return it due to running too large. I got a small but it overpowered my frame and the collar seemed too large for the cropped coat. That's why the models don't have the coat buttoned. I am 5'5" and weigh 133lbs. Size down.

NOPE!

Submitted 1 month ago

By Dalenasam

From Undisclosed

Not only is this not worth the price, it arrived stuffed into the shipping bag. No plastic or garment bag to protect it. No hanger. Not even folded nicely. One would think it was ordered from a used clothing/thrifting website. Returning.

5 stars for warmth and quality. 2 stars for shipping

Submitted 2 months ago

By Margarita

From Undisclosed

I love this piece! I appreciate the non syntetic lining and the amount of wool in the body. I like the cropped oversized look. For reference I'm 5'3'', 115 pounds, long legs, short torso. The XXS fits well, although I feel an XS would work as well. If I could rate shipping and fit consistency I would give a 2. I noticed the construction and fit varies slightly between colors. I found the right fit after trying 3 of them in the same size (2 navy, 1 yellow). The shipping was disappointing: I ordered a Navy one and a Yellow one in XXS. Both came the same day. the navy was nicely packed in a plastic bag inside a box with a hanger. the yellow one was tossed in the typical Banana black plastic bag for shipping; no hanger, no clear plastic bag to protect the coat. I would have kept both with the discounted price but the way the yellow was shipped made it look not worthy. I miss when Banana send the coats with the black zipped dust protector.

Stylish quality

Submitted 2 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Italian Melton Wool-Blend Peacoat

I LOVE this jacket! The quality of the fabric and jacket construction is unmistakable. I feel so sophisticated and stylish because I always get compliments when I wear it!

Fab - blue - lis

Submitted 2 months ago

By Tracy D

From Undisclosed

I bought the butter yellow one and actually hated the color. It's more mustard yellow- which is still beautiful. But I wanted it more buttery. I did buy it online - when I returned it in store I found the blue one which I loved! Heavy wool material. Gorgeous dresses up or down.

Luvvvvvv it!!

Submitted 2 months ago

By Michelle

From Undisclosed

Great quality and so comfy.

Beautifully made coat

Submitted 2 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Italian Melton Wool-Blend Peacoat

I've been looking for a pea coat for awhile. I wanted something a bit longer so by the time I decided to order this coat, the navy was sold out in xxs. I ordered the yellow, hoping it was a butter yellow but it was mustard yellow so I returned it. When xxs became available I ordered it. I usually take xs in BR. I'm 5'1", 101 lbs. The length is good. The xxs fits great with rooms for a heavy sweater. The coat is beautifully made. I received 4 compliments the 1st time I wore it. I'm very happy with my purchase.

quality

Submitted 2 months ago

By Christine

From Undisclosed

Love the cut , style and comfort and warmth, I'm short , so the coat doesn't overpower me , I bought in yellow also xs is roomy , I weigh 100'and 5.2