As Seen On

See how our community is styling our favorite pieces in real life.

Reviews

Review Snapshot
4.2
25 Star Ratings
92%
of respondents would recommend this to a friend
Ratings Distribution
Overall size
Width
Most Liked Positive Review
Timeless style & All Day Comfort, Solid Investment

This Mesi leather cap toe Oxford shoes from banana republic exceeded mg expectations. The learher is soft yet sturdy, with sleek design that works both for business and dressy occasions. What impressed me most is the comfort. True to size with quality craftsmanship that feels premium. Highly recomme...

Versus
Most Liked Negative Review
Received a Worn damaged pair

As a platinum member, I was really shocked to received a worn pair. I opened the box which was nicely packaged inside of another box. Clearly it wasn't a packaging issue. I haven't put them on at all because clearly I could see that they were damaged. The bottom soles were scratched and darkened. Th...

Write a Review
18 Customer Reviews
These are not women's shoes-they are mens shoes!!

Submitted 2 months ago

By carol

From Undisclosed

Searched for a pair of oxfords and thought I hit the jackpot with these. Ordered my usual 8 1/2 and when I opened the box the shoes are huge and not a women's shoe! I decided to try them on and yes, a man's shoe as it as huge and not just a 1/2 size but at least 2 sizes, Disappointing and back they go.

Stylish, Sexy, and Worth Every Penny

Submitted 6 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about Mesi Leather Cap-Toe Oxford

The Mesi Leather Cap-Toe Oxford is an incredibly sexy pair of shoes. The craftsmanship is excellent, the leather feels premium, and the cap-toe design adds a refined touch of elegance. They're stylish, versatile, and absolutely worth it. Highly recommended!

Received a Worn damaged pair

Submitted 6 months ago

By Ridge B

From Undisclosed

As a platinum member, I was really shocked to received a worn pair. I opened the box which was nicely packaged inside of another box. Clearly it wasn't a packaging issue. I haven't put them on at all because clearly I could see that they were damaged. The bottom soles were scratched and darkened. The sticker at the bottom for the leather composition was worn and peeled off. There were scuffs all over the pair of shoes. They looked pretty beat up. There were worn marks as in folds in the leather too. I contacted customer service pretty upset as I intended to wear these shoes at a wedding. They said I have to return the shoes to have a refund which honestly while I understand just adds a chore to my busy schedule on top of not having shoes to wear to the wedding. They gave me a 15% discount for my next order... honestly as a platinum member I felt pretty let down by the whole experience altogether. I bought a new pair hoping they will get here early enough and hopefully not worn or damaged. Now I am down 300 dollars and hope to at least get my refund. Standard have really dropped. I am still quite shocked by the whole thing to be honest. I wonder if they are having a sale is because they are sending off worn used shoes from display in the store. If so... maybe go buy it in store and assess for yourself before buying. They clearly have dropped their standards disappointingly so.

Nice shoe for the sale price

Submitted 6 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about Mesi Leather Cap-Toe Oxford

Great quality, smells nice. The last is narrow, but that fits me better.

These shoes are a fantastic find!

Submitted 6 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Mesi Leather Cap-Toe Oxford

The craftsmanship is top-notch, with impeccable finishing that adds to their durability and style. Aesthetically, they're absolutely beautiful, with a sleek design that turns heads. Highly recommend for anyone seeking comfort and elegance in one package!

Nice and comfortable.

Submitted 6 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Mesi Leather Cap-Toe Oxford

The leather is a little too soft.

Good shoe

Submitted 6 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about Mesi Leather Cap-Toe Oxford

Decent shoe. Classic look. Some imperfections in the leather. Would benefit from any grip on the sole.

High quality footwear

Submitted 6 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Reviewed at

gap.com

Comments about Mesi Leather Cap-Toe Oxford

Love the half size since I'm in between sizes. Been a loyal customer for two decades.

Timeless style & All Day Comfort, Solid Investment

Submitted 7 months ago

By HAYAL

From Undisclosed

This Mesi leather cap toe Oxford shoes from banana republic exceeded mg expectations. The learher is soft yet sturdy, with sleek design that works both for business and dressy occasions. What impressed me most is the comfort. True to size with quality craftsmanship that feels premium. Highly recommend if you are looking for black dress shoes.

Polished well

Submitted 8 months ago

By anonymous

From Undisclosed

Verified Buyer

Sweepstakes Entry

Comments about Mesi Leather Cap-Toe Oxford

Comfortable and stylish